Think about the companies that are doing well in your segment, the ones everybody else measures themselves against. You’d know who they are without looking it up.

Ask what put them there and the answers come quickly. A better product. More scale. A stronger dealer network. A head start that nobody’s been able to close. All of that’s real, and I wouldn’t argue with any of it.

I’d add one thing, and I feel pretty strongly about it. I’d venture to say the companies doing best in a space are better marketers than the rest of it, and they’ve been better for a long time. At some point they figured out that investing in marketing as something more than the promotions department pays off, and they kept doing it. That means the strongest marketing you’ve seen may well belong to a company you’re competing with.

 

What you’ve been comparing against

Put that next to how marketing gets judged inside your own business. Now and then a leader tells me they’ve spent a lot on marketing and it hasn’t worked, and on the version they’ve been paying for, I think they’re right. I wouldn’t invest in it right now either if it were being done that way. I mean the work. I don’t blame the people doing it, and I think they’re usually working with what they’ve been given.

What’s missing from the verdict is a reference point. Spending a lot is relative. A lot compared to what? Nobody in the building knows what marketing should cost to do properly, or what it ought to produce, because there’s nothing inside the company to compare it to. In a lot of the businesses I work with, there isn’t any formal marketing training inside. I’d say that happens in big corporations too, never mind a mid-sized B2B company where marketing’s never been an emphasis point. So the budget gets argued against the only number anybody has, which is last year’s.

 

The version you’ve seen becomes the version you fund

That’s how it compounds. A function nobody’s treated as strategic doesn’t get people who’ve done it at a high level, and without them nobody puts real money behind it, because nothing says the money would come back. Each year’s budget is a fair read of the year before, and the year before was shaped by the budget ahead of it. Nothing from outside the building ever gets into that comparison, so the bar stays about where it started.

 

The companies at the top are already setting the standard

So use them. I think the companies at the top of your segment are already the standard your customers hold you to. I don’t think a customer comparing you with them is grading on last year’s plan. They notice who talks about their business like they get it, and who sounds like the other four companies that showed up at their door. I’d assume every bit of your business is under competitive threat all the time, and that a good share of the threat comes from companies who’ve been investing in this longer than you have.

Some of it you can look for from the outside. Watch whether their story holds together from one place you meet them to the next. And listen for whether their marketing talks to a customer with enough relevance that the customer knows they get it, without sounding like everybody else in the category. I think that second one’s harder to pull off than it looks. Anybody on your team can study them that way and write down what they see, and that list is the standard you’ll hold your own work to.

 

Look at who’s running it

The other thing worth finding out is who runs their marketing. A strong function has a leader who wants to be highly involved with sales and highly involved in the business, and who brings the infrastructure and operating discipline to make the work execute month after month. That’s what makes it strategic in practice. If you can, find out who that person reports to and how much of their week goes to the sales leaders. Those two answers tell you a lot about how seriously they take the function, and it’s a fair pair of questions to ask about your own.

 

Funding it starts as a leadership decision

None of this happens overnight, and I’m not going to pretend it does. The shift’s going to take a mentality commitment first, in how leadership thinks about what marketing is for. That’s usually got to come from the top, because nobody lower down can make it on leadership’s behalf. Then it’ll need a resource commitment and an alignment commitment between the functions. It’s real work, and it costs money before it pays anything back.

A successful business gets to decide whether that’s worth doing. I won’t tell anybody it’s an easy call. I’d just make it as an investment decision, judged against what a strong version of the function returns for the companies you compete with, instead of as last year’s line with a percentage added or taken off.

 

Get a reference point before the next budget

Before the next budget decision on marketing, go see what strong marketing looks like in your own segment. Look hard at the companies doing best in it. What does their marketing do that yours doesn’t? Who runs it, and how close is that person to the sales team?

Pull together what they’ve put out over the last year, the same way you’d pull your own, and lay the two side by side. Read both the way a customer would, and be honest about which one sounds like it understands the customer’s business. Then ask your sales team which of those companies they’d least like to run into on a call, and why. Their answers will tell you what the standard in your segment is better than any benchmark report.

Write down what you find. Then judge your own function against that list, instead of against what it produced last year, and put the budget conversation on the same footing.